This “dependability-conscientiousness” factor is a single scale or preference. Scores on integrity tests tell us only about this factor, nothing about the respondent’s intelligence, ambition, social skill, poise, judgement or health.
The theory behind Overt tests being that we all view ourselves as normal and therefore it would be abnormal to have not stolen, but rather the candidate may admit to stealing an amount as they believe everyone steals and therefore they would not be normal if they admitted nothing.
Both types have strong research data and have been proven to work well in screening out employees that potentially could be counterproductive.
As a single measure integrity tests are one of the most predictive indicators of counter-productive work behaviours and on-the-job performance.
Integrity tests have also been shown to be good at predicting safety behaviours and safety outcomes. Read more about safety assessments
Niche Consulting has a integrity test we have developed NZ norms for and have research backing its validity in the NZ context.
“I started using stand alone integrity testing during candidate screening of Production staff after having had great success using it alongside other tools as part of our selection process for Service staff. Over a period of several years using the integrity test to identify those candidates that would be easier to manage helped me develop a more cohesive team of willing and co operative personnel. I believe it works well and is a cost effective and simple tool in application that provides further insight during the screening phase that has helped me avoid some of the pitfalls of the employing the wrong people.” - GR, Branch Manager
"We utilised the Integrity test as part of the recruitment process and found it to be a useful assessment tool. It provided, on the whole, accurate information about whether the candidate was likely to display productive or counter-productive behaviours in the workplace. We found that combining this test with other selections assessments gave us a better understanding of the candidate’s levels of conscientiousness – an area we were particularly interested in as this is a key predictor of job performance. I would definitely recommend this Integrity test." - MB, HR Manager
"We were looking for a screening tool for safety critical roles and we asked Niche consulting to search out a tool which met our criteria. We needed a tool which would be able to accurately identify risk tendencies or impulsive behaviour and a tool which was not daunting to a population which had minimal education and English as a second language. It also needed to be economical and easy to administer. Neisha researched many tools claiming to be for safety critical roles but found only one tool which satisfied her rigorous inspection....We found the tool significantly predicted those with negative safety attitudes." - AM, OD Manager